Gun Control & Mental Health: Initial Responses from AAPI Community Advocates

On December 14, 2013, Adam Lanza killed seven adults and 20 children in the town of Newton, Connecticut, including his mother. As the media frenzy began, stories emerged on the reasons behind Lanza’s actions and what could have, if anything, prevented them. Speculation grew about Lanza’s unconfirmed diagnosis of Asperger’s syndrome, his usage of guns, and his love of video games.

Of particular concern to people in the disability community was the conflation between violence and mental illness and specifically, a conflation between violence and people with autism and Asperger’s syndrome.

As individuals grapple on how to respond to the epidemic of mass shootings, there is a renewed examination of the mental health system and the unmet needs of people with mental illness. For many families, communities and institutions, this marks the start of a national dialogue on this issue. Meanwhile, community-based advocates and others working in the mental health field have been on the frontlines, sounding the alarm.

Policymakers at the state and federal level are addressing gaps in the mental health system in the form of proposed bills and executive actions. On January 16, 2013, President Obama released a plan on reducing gun violence, with a number of executive orders on mental health care. The Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor & Pensions held a full hearing on the state of the mental health system, with testimony from officials representing federal agencies the following week.

Clearly, there is now more attention on the mental health needs of Americans. But what about the needs of Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders with mental illness? I asked two advocates on mental health in the AAPI community for their take on the proposed changes and the issues most salient for the AAPI community: Dr. DJ Ida, Executive Director of NAAPIMHA (National Asian American Pacific Islander Mental Health Association) and Jonathan Griggs, Rehab Activity Leader of NAAPIEN (National Asian American Pacific Islander Empowerment Network).

The following are excerpts of their comments:

What do you think most people do not understand about mental illness and violence?

Most mental health clients are NOT violent, in fact, they are more likely to be victims of violence than perpetrators of violence… Media does not focus on the truths of mental health and guns, but more on the myths of mental health and violence. – JG

While it is important to raise awareness around mental health, it is important to not equate mental health with violence in the current debate on gun control. The national dialog should have a broader perspective and recognize that addressing mental health is key to improving the overall health and well being of this country, and is not designed for the sole purpose of ending violence. – DJI

What do you want to share with the general public about the needs of AAPIs with mental illness, in particular within the mental health system?

[AAPIs] need to overcome the barriers to treatment, come up with solutions, and work on anti-stigma campaigns to overcome the fear and distrust of mental health providers and systems. [We also need] more funding for AAPI consumer-run programs. – JG

In spite of the image of being the “model minority”, AAPIs, like any other population, experience the full range of mental health problems, from those who will never have a serious problem to those with severe and life threatening problems that need attention…The issues facing AANHPIs [Asian American Native Hawaiian Pacific Islanders] are complex and reflect the great diversity within and between the various subpopulations. These differences are reflected in the different levels of historical trauma, specific cultural values and belief systems, language needs, generational differences, acculturation levels, and individual factors facing the individual/family/community. Improving the current workforce is critical to meeting the unique needs of the community and must include bi-lingual paraprofessionals, as well as consumers who can be trained as Wellness Coaches. Mental health for AANHPIs encompasses all aspects of the person’s life and experiences, including immigration status, education level, loss of status, racism, homophobia, and other factors impacting a person’s overall health and well being. – DJI

Despite the tragic events that prompted this attention on the mental health system, perhaps it is a constructive step forward.

What are your thoughts on this issue? What are some actions AAPI communities should take when it comes to including and welcoming the voices of AAPIs with mental illness?

Guest Blogger Alice Wong is a disabled/Asian-American/news junkie/night owl/advocate/researcher. You can find her on Twitter @SFdirewolf

Selected additional resources:

Active Campaigns

  • Graphic says "Asian Americans say no to Zionism and Islamophobia! - 70+ Asian American and allied organizations tell The Asian American Foundation: Drop Jonathan Greenblatt! The ADL is not an ally to Asian American communities, organizations, and movements."

    Say NO to Zionism and Islamophobia!

    Say NO to Zionism and Islamophobia! 70+ Asian American and allied organizations tell The Asian American Foundation: Drop Jonathan Greenblatt! The ADL is NOT AN ALLY to Asian American communities, organizations, and movements.
  • Duotone read and deep dark green image of protesters facing militarized police officers in the background. Main text reads: To District Attorney Jenkins: Drop the charges against the Bay Bridge 78! We are part of a long linesage of people who have used civil disobedience to help bend the arc of history towards justice - from the civil rights movement to the right against apartheid in South Africa. 18MR's logo is on the bottom right corner.

    I was Arrested on the Bay Bridge

    I was arrested for demanding an end to genocide. We are part of a long lineage of people who have used civil disobedience to help bend the arc of history toward justice – from the Civil Rights Movement to the fight against apartheid in South Africa.  As a Filipino American organizer for racial justice, I’ve […]

    PARDON APSC4: Our beloved family APSC 4: Borey “Peejay” Ai, Nghiep “Ke” Lam, Chanthon Bun, and Maria Legarda are at risk of deportation. Tell Governor Newsom to pardon them NOW so they can remain home with their families and community. Here’s some things you can do!

Also On 18MR